Skip to main content

The "how" doesn't really matter.

Theories about Christ's death are not Christianity: they are explanations of how it works.
C.S Lewis in Mere Christianity.

One of the books that has had the most profound impact on my (and I suspect many others) spiritual life is Mere Christianity by C.S Lewis. It is, at once, accessible to most believers and a beautiful example of how the English language is not so vulgar after all. This may stem from the fact that Lewis, over and above being a philosopher, was a student and professor of Literature, and indeed the author of one of the finest fantasy series' ever written, The Chronicles of Narnia. What Lewis sets out to accomplish in this book is, not to expound something I could call 'my religion,' but to expound 'mere' Christianity, which is what it is and what it was long before I was born and whether I like it or not. This is one of the things I appreciate the most about this work. He is not telling us what it means to be Baptist or Methodist or even Anglican. He is trying, as a fallible human being himself, to boil Christianity down to the lowest common denominator. Enter the quote from the top of the post.

When I read that line from the chapter entitled "The Perfect Penitent" I was struck by both the truth of the statement itself and also one of the greatest flaws we, as believers, have: making mountains out of molehills, as it were. You see, one of the things I learned in seminary was that there are a variety of theories for each aspect of Christian doctrine. For instance, we spent and entire portion of our Systematic Theology class hashing out the doctrine of the Trinity. The perfect evidence of this is that while the Bible fits neatly into one volume that, depending on the font size, can be put in one's pocket, there are entire libraries filled with books about the Bible and all aspects of Christianity. In seeing that it is hard to take seriously the old adage, "The Bible says it, I believe it, that settles it." While I agree with the underlying sentiment of that statement it seems that for the majority of believers that doesn't settle it! Even with just one authoritative body of Scripture there are a variety of theories regarding the essential doctrines contained therein.

Lets take the issue of Christ's atonement as an example here. If you type in "atonement theories" into Google you can find several lists of those theories. The website gives us four theories: ransom, penal substitution, satisfaction and moral. Each of these is espoused by various flavors of Christianity such as Roman Catholics, evangelicals, orthodox and liberal Christians. Each of these theories is an effort to explain exactly how Christ's sacrifice saved us from our sins. As Lewis puts it, this is a desire to not only agree that some law of nature works but to understand how it works as well. We believe that there is gravity, for example, but how does gravity actually work? I think the point that Lewis is trying to make is one that we should take heed of today, it doesn't really matter. Figuring out the "how" of the atonement is far less important than understanding that it happened at all. Beyond that it is much more important to understand the "who" of the atonement, e.g. Jesus Christ atoned you and I. I seriously doubt that when we stand before the Almighty He is going to quiz us on atonement theories to make sure we had it all figured out before we arrived in Heaven. In fact, I believe that if the "how" was that important it would have been made plain in the Bible so that there would be no question.

Now, let me say this so there is less room for misunderstanding. I do not believe that meditating on deep theological questions is completely useless. That, I believe, is part of understanding our faith and growing more mature as Christians. However, when our faith becomes nothing more than a cerebral exercise to the point that it grows impersonal we have a serious problem. First and foremost the Christian faith is about a relationship with a person, and that person is the Triune God of the universe. Understanding how God does everything is secondary to being in a relationship with Him. One of the beauties of the Christian faith is that it can withstand critical thought and you can plumb the depths of it until you die and never scratch the surface. On the other hand it is simple enough for a child to understand it and even the most unintellectual person can grasp the truth contained in the Gospel.

In American Christianity I see this issue most vividly in the divisions over theories regarding the end times. There are those who believe that the Church will be "raptured" before the Tribulation, those who say after the Tribulation and those who say during. No matter how hard I try I cannot figure out what difference it makes. This much is clear to me from the Bible, one day Christ will return for His people. Here is my question, how does figuring out when Christ is going to do that effect our lives? Are we going to be more or less likely to share the Gospel with people depending on our view of the end? Does our eschatelogical view effect people coming into a relationship with Christ? I would submit a hearty, NO. Does this mean we should spend no time pondering these things? Heavens no, but let us place them in the proper place as secondary to the larger message of the Gospel.

Let me wrap this up by taking us back to the quote from Lewis. Christianity is not about agreeing with the correct atonement theory. Christianity is about agreeing that Christ died for you and accepting that sacrifice however it was actually carried out. Never forget that our faith is not about a theory it is about a person and that person once lived on this earth, He died, was resurrected and now lives forevermore seated at the right hand of God. How did that all work? I have no idea but I know it happened and I know whom I have believed and I am convinced that He is able to guard what I have entrusted to Him until that day (2 Tim. 1:!2).



Popular posts from this blog

Characteristics of a Godly Watchman Pt. 1: Vigilance

Most everyone has heard an alarm go off. It may be something as mundane as the alarm clock every morning that tells us it is time to get up and get ready for work, or it may be something as frightening as a fire alarm. No matter what the specific purpose of the alarm they all share one common theme: they are meant to alert people and warn them of impending danger.

In Joel 2:1 the Lord commands the prophet to; Blow a trumpet in Zion, and sound an alarm on My holy mountainbecause the day of the Lord is coming. That is, God’s judgment is coming upon Israel for their sinfulness. Further along in the chapter, in verse 15, Joel is again commanded to blow a trumpet but this time it is to call the assembly of the people together so that they can, consecrate a fast. This tells us two important things about the role, or the duty, of the prophet of God. First, it tells us that the prophet is to act as an alarm to warn the people of God’s coming judgment. Secondly, the prophet is also to be the mo…

A Letter to Christian Girls.

Charm is deceitful and beauty is vain, But a woman who fears the Lord, she shall be praised. Proverbs 31:30

Tonight my wife has been asked to speak to a group of Christian girls on the issues of dating, purity, relationships, etc. As part of that, the youth pastor of this church asked if I would write a letter to the group of young women from a guy's point of view. Now, I can't say as I remember ever having written a letter to a group of teenage girls but I do have some pretty strong feelings about the way our culture has portrayed love, marriage and particularly women. So, what I would like to do in this post is reproduce for you some of this letter. I may add some here and subtract some there but I want this to be my letter to all the Christian, young ladies out there.

What I want to do, through this letter, is share some things from a “guys” point of view because it’s no secret that we see things a little differently than you ladies do. You may think that all we think about …

My Boss is a Jewish Carpenter?

Have you ever seen that bumper sticker? The one that says "My boss is a Jewish carpenter." I certainly have and generally when I see it I quietly agree with the driver and take the encouragement that comes with seeing a fellow soldier in the Lord's army. Just this evening, though, I had a thought as I was driving home from Bible study. "Should Jesus be my boss?" Now before you go casting judgment on the thought let me explain what I mean. I propose that instead if being a "boss" we should be looking at God and Christ as "Master." I'll explain by looking at some differences in the idea of boss and master.

Difference #1: Why were you hired?

When an individual is hired for a job by an employer it is for a specific reason. Perhaps a particular skill, talent or level of education qualifies someone for a particular job. The employer hires the person that is the most qualified to fulfill the task. Granted, this is the way it is supposed to work. …